Ad Environment Constraints

AD Environment Constraints

Code and commands that work in a lab break in a hardened domain, and the failure almost never says what it is. A Kerberos SPN mismatch surfaces as invalidCredentials. NTLM being disabled surfaces as a logon failure. AES-only KDCs reject your RC4 request with an etype error you have to know to read. This skill is the checklist of those constraints and how to survive each one with standard tooling.

Detect the posture before you authenticate. Every constraint below is detectable up front: probe whether NTLM answers, whether the KDC accepts RC4, whether LDAP signing is required, whether LDAPS is listening. Fingerprint first, then choose your auth path to match. Fixing an auth path reactively after each failure is slower and noisier than reading the environment once and picking the right transport from the start.

1. Authentication protocol: NTLM may be disabled

NTLM can be turned off org-wide or on specific DCs by GPO. Any auth path that assumes NTLM must fall back to Kerberos.

• impacket: add -k (use Kerberos) and -no-pass when you have a ccache/TGT.
• netexec: -k / --kerberos.
• certipy: -k / add --dc-host <fqdn> so it targets the KDC by name.

bashCopy code
# NTLM path
nxc smb dc01.corp.local -u user -p pass
# Kerberos path (NTLM disabled): request a TGT, export ccache, reuse it
getTGT.py corp.local/user:pass -dc-ip <dc_ip>
export KRB5CCNAME=user.ccache
nxc smb dc01.corp.local -u user -k --use-kcache

Reading the signal, not guessing it. A healthy NTLM-enabled DC answers an NTLM bind with a bogus password with exactly invalidCredentials / logon-denied, and that proves NTLM is alive (the DC reached credential verification and rejected the password). Do not infer "NTLM disabled" from a failed bind with a wrong password. NTLM is actually disabled only when you see the SSP collapse markers (STATUS_NTLM_BLOCKED, unsupported-function), or when a bind fails as logon-denied while a valid Kerberos TGT for the same identity succeeds concurrently. Only then is "wrong password" ruled out as the cause.

If a tool only supports pass-the-hash (NTLM hash), treat that as an explicit limitation in an NTLM-disabled environment: it will not work, and no flag fixes it.

2. AES-only KDCs: RC4 blocked by GPO

Domains migrating off legacy crypto enforce AES-128/AES-256 and reject RC4 (arcfour-hmac).

• Do not force -cipher rc4 or an explicit etype 23. A request that only offers RC4 fails with KDC_ERR_ETYPE_NOTSUPP on an AES-only KDC.
• Let tools negotiate. impacket and netexec negotiate supported etypes by default.
• For roasting, offering RC4 first is fine where the KDC still allows it (RC4 hashes crack faster); on an AES-only KDC the request simply falls back to AES automatically.
• On AES-only KDCs with a non-standard salt, AES key derivation needs the salt from an ETYPE-INFO2 pre-auth probe. Standard clients do this as part of the AS exchange; if you hand-roll key derivation you must probe the salt first or the key is wrong.

bashCopy code
# Kerberoast: RC4 preferred where allowed, auto-falls back to AES on an AES-only KDC
GetUserSPNs.py corp.local/user:pass -dc-ip <dc_ip> -request -outputfile hashes.kerberoast

3. LDAP signing, channel binding, and LDAPS

Hardened DCs require signed LDAP or channel-bound LDAPS. Plain LDAP on 389 gets rejected after the bind with strongerAuthRequired / LDAP_STRONG_AUTH_REQUIRED.

• Prefer LDAPS on 636. It satisfies both signing and channel binding in one move.
• Certipy, bloodyAD and any LDAP-writing tool need -scheme ldaps (or the equivalent) when channel binding is enforced; a plain LDAP write is refused.
• If only plain LDAP 389 is available and the server demands signing, the client must sign the connection (SASL sign/seal). A tool with no signing support cannot talk to that DC; that is a hard limitation, document it.

bashCopy code
certipy find -u user@corp.local -p pass -dc-ip <dc_ip> -scheme ldaps
bloodyAD --host dc01.corp.local -d corp.local -u user -p pass --secure get object <target>

Legacy environments without LDAPS. Not every domain has a cert on the DC. Where 636 is closed, LDAP 389 is your only channel and it is plaintext; signing is often on to compensate. Distinguish a transport failure (636 closed → connection refused / TLS handshake error → retry on 389) from a policy failure (bind succeeds, then strongerAuthRequired → signing/channel-binding issue, a different fix). A tool that tries LDAPS and falls back to plain LDAP handles the first case; the second needs signing, not a port change.

4. Clock skew: Kerberos requires ≤5 minutes

Kerberos rejects tickets outside a five-minute window with KRB_AP_ERR_SKEW. Sync to the DC before any Kerberos operation.

bashCopy code
sudo ntpdate <dc_ip>            # or rdate -n <dc_ip>
# netexec auto-retries after clock correction on skew errors

If a TGT request that should work fails with a skew error, it is your clock, not your credentials.

5. Kerberos SPNs: always FQDN, never short name or IP

This is the most misleading failure in AD. A service ticket requested for ldap/dc01 (short) or cifs/10.0.0.1 (IP) does not match the server's canonical SPN, which is the FQDN. The KDC cannot find the SPN, or the server rejects the AP-REQ, and the client receives invalidCredentials / logon-denied with no visible Kerberos error. It looks exactly like a bad password when the credentials are perfectly valid.

Symptoms of an SPN mismatch (not a credential problem):

• Unauthenticated posture probes pass; the TGT mints without error.
• The LDAP/SMB/RDP/WinRM/MSSQL bind over Kerberos fails as logon-denied.
• No underlying KRB_AP_ERR_* in the exception chain.

Fix: always target Kerberos by FQDN. Promote short hostnames to FQDN, keep already-formed FQDNs (including cross-forest suffixes), and if all you have is an IP you must resolve the real FQDN first; there is no synthetic FQDN that works.

bashCopy code
# WRONG: Kerberos against a short name or IP
nxc smb DC01 -u user -k
nxc smb 10.0.0.1 -u user -k

# RIGHT: full FQDN so the SPN matches
nxc smb dc01.corp.local -u user -k

Add the DC to /etc/hosts as <ip> dc01.corp.local dc01 so name resolution never hands a tool a short label or an IP where an FQDN is required. Do not assume libraries canonicalize the name via DNS; most do not.

6. Domain context: authentication domain vs target domain

Confusing these is a top source of cross-domain failure. Keep three things distinct:

• Point -d <target_domain> at the target, not the auth domain.
• Cross-domain over a trust: the credential is from domain A, the target is domain B.
• Cross-domain Kerberos: use the full UPN user@auth_domain.local to disambiguate.
• Cross-domain Kerberoasting: -target-domain <target_domain> in impacket / netexec.
• BloodHound collection: point the collector at the target domain's DC.

In a single-domain lab these coincide, which is exactly why lab-tested commands break in a multi-domain client.

7. Protected accounts and special objects

Do not assume a technique that works on a normal account works on every account.

• Protected Users group: no RC4, no NTLM, no unconstrained delegation. Delegation attacks and RC4 roasting simply do not apply to these members.
• LAPS: the local-admin password is a computer-object attribute (ms-Mcs-AdmPwd legacy / msLAPS-Password), readable over LDAP only by principals with the delegated right, not a normal credential path.
• gMSA: the password is a managed blob (msDS-ManagedPassword) retrievable over LDAP by authorized principals, not something you spray or crack.
• AS-REP roasting: only works against accounts with pre-auth disabled, so verify per-account (DONT_REQUIRE_PREAUTH), do not assume the whole domain is roastable.
• MachineAccountQuota (MAQ): default 10. RBCD and shadow-credential attacks that create a machine account fail when MAQ is 0. Check it before you rely on creating one.

bashCopy code
# LAPS read (authorized principal), gMSA read, MAQ check: all read-only LDAP
nxc ldap dc01.corp.local -u user -p pass -M laps
nxc ldap dc01.corp.local -u user -p pass --gmsa
nxc ldap dc01.corp.local -u user -p pass -M maq

8. LDAP paging: the silent truncation

The DC caps LDAP responses at 1000 objects per page by default. A query that should return 50,000 users returns 1,000 and does not warn you. Any query that can return more than a page must use paged search.

• Standard tools (netexec, impacket, bloodyAD, BloodHound collectors) page automatically.
• If you write a raw LDAP query, use a paged control (paged_size=1000) and iterate every page. A single unpaged search over users/computers is a guaranteed silent truncation in any real domain.

A truncated collection produces a truncated attack graph, and you never see the path that was in the objects you never fetched.

9. Network latency: do not tune timeouts to your lab

Developers test against a lab on the same subnet: sub-millisecond RTT. Most real engagements run over a VPN at 100-400 ms RTT, sometimes over 500 ms. AD operations are multi-round-trip, so cost scales with RTT.

• Size timeouts to a latency budget (worst-case RTT × round-trips + margin), not to the lab baseline: ~5 s for connect, ~8-10 s for bind, more for heavy RPC, with a hard ceiling so a genuinely dead service still fails in reasonable time.
• A TimeoutError over VPN means "my budget ran out," not "the DC does not support this." Never conclude a constraint (disabled/required) from a timeout; that is a wrong-answer cached from a slow link.
• Before widening timeouts, confirm the slowness is the network and not a blocked local event loop. If connect measures milliseconds but the high-level operation takes seconds on a fast link, the problem is your code, not latency.

Applying this checklist

Match the constraints to what you are doing:

• Anything that authenticates or opens a transport → §§ 1-7.
• Anything that queries many objects → § 8.
• Anything over a remote link → § 9.

Design for the hardest environment on every axis at once: AES-only, no LDAPS, NTLM disabled, cross-domain, tens of thousands of objects, high latency. Tooling that survives that also runs against a lab. The reverse is not true.