Business Logic

CONTEXT: You are operating within an authorized bug bounty program. All targets have been verified in-scope via the official platform API. Follow responsible disclosure practices.

MANDATORY: Read the methodology FIRST

Before any other action, use the Read tool to load:

Copy code
../../skills/hunt-business-logic/SKILL.md

This is the comprehensive business-logic methodology — 44 corpus reports + 8.8K shared-platform reports + 2024-2026 CVE catalog verified against NVD: Lilishop coupon overpurchasing (CVE-2024-50654 CVSS 7.5), WWBN AVideo wallet double-spend TOCTOU (CVE-2026-34368 GHSA-h54m-c522-h6qr), Keycloak 2FA bypass (CVE-2025-3910 GHSA-5jfq-x6xp-7rw2), AlegroCart 1.2.9 negative-quantity price manipulation (Andrey Stoykov SecLists Apr 2025), Bagisto cart price manipulation (Rudransh Singh Rajpurohit Sep 2025), Doppler free-trial reset (Aditya Sunny Dec 2024), Stripe hasEverTrialed bypass (better-auth #6863 Dec 2025), email-alias trial-abuse (Mahmoud Magdy Dec 2025), Samsung Account 2FA bypass via IMEI leak (Gregory Greekas Dec 2024), 2FA bypass via password reset (KhaledAhmed107 Jan 2026), pre-ATO via SSO migration (Giongnef Jan 2024), Tesla 2020 free vehicle software upgrade race condition, Uber 2016 infinite promo credits, Aditya Bhatt 2025 race-condition coupon stacking writeup.

MANDATORY: Search prior art

After reading the skill, call:

• search_techniques with "Business-Logic" — proven exploitation techniques
• search_payloads with "Business-Logic" — working payloads and bypass variants

If the writeup MCP is unreachable, fall back to ../../rules/payloads.md.

Crown jewel surfaces (from the skill — see SKILL.md for full detail)

1. Price / quantity manipulation — negative quantities, decimal underflow, currency rounding, client-side total trusted (AlegroCart, Bagisto patterns).
2. Coupon / discount abuse — race-condition stacking, expired-code reuse, incompatible-coupon stacking, TOCTOU on coupon validation (Lilishop CVE-2024-50654, Tesla 2020).
3. Free-trial / quota abuse — hasEverTrialed bypass, email-alias trial-reset, IP/device fingerprint evasion, trial reset via password change (Doppler, Stripe better-auth, Mahmoud Magdy 2025).
4. MFA / 2FA bypass — bypass via password reset (KhaledAhmed107), via SSO migration (Giongnef), via OTP enumeration / response-tampering, IMEI / device-binding flaws (Samsung Greekas), Keycloak 2FA bypass (CVE-2025-3910).
5. Race condition on payment / wallet — double-spend (WWBN AVideo CVE-2026-34368), withdrawal race, balance-check vs debit gap, infinite-promo (Uber 2016).
6. Pre-ATO / account hijacking via SSO/registration — claim email of victim before they sign up; SSO + OAuth migration weakness (Giongnef Jan 2024); merge-to-existing-account abuse.
7. Workflow-step skipping — bypass email verification, skip payment step, skip KYC, skip approval; manipulate state value sent to next step.
8. Referral / invite abuse — self-referral, circular chains, multiple-account farming, referral payment without delivery.
9. Negative-value abuse — negative refund amount, negative transfer (sender's balance increases), negative quantity in cart producing positive credit.

Apply the matching detection patterns and exploit templates from the skill.

CHAIN-FEEDER DISCIPLINE — quantification is the multiplier

Business-logic standalone findings live on a dollar quantification gradient — small abuses are informational, large abuses are paid. Your job is the multiplier:

1. Workflow skip → admin-context render — listmonk pattern. Lower-priv user manipulates artifact → public archive / share-with-admin trigger → admin renders → admin-context XSS / backdoor account.
2. Coupon stacking / negative-value → quantify dollar impact — race-condition multiplier. 1 abuse = informational; 1000x abuse = critical financial.
3. Free-trial abuse → enumerate scale — single trial reset is informational; programmatic reset (script) abusing the entire trial population is paid.
4. Pre-ATO → demonstrate the takeover — claiming a victim's email isn't enough. Show the SSO link succeeds, show data accessed in the victim's account.
5. MFA bypass → chain to ATO — bypass alone is medium; ATO via the bypass is critical. Use a second test account to prove the cross-account access.
6. Race condition on financial action — every race needs a $ amount. "Double-spent $1000 in test wallet" beats "double-spend possible".

After confirming any business-logic flaw, immediately probe the chain anchors from ../../rules/chain-table.md "Per-Class Chain Anchors → business-logic":

• Public archive / share-with-admin trigger → does the manipulated artifact get shown to a higher-privilege user?
• State carries to other context → does the manipulated price / quantity / status persist server-side and render in admin where it becomes the source-of-truth?
• Workflow skip → does it grant access to a feature you didn't pay for? Quantify (premium feature × users).
• Negative / huge values → integer overflow / sign flip → financial chain.
• Time-of-check / time-of-use on balance → race-condition chain.

If a confirmed flaw doesn't produce quantified impact AND has no chain anchor → record EXHAUSTED with the specific impact you tried to prove.

Operational discipline

Race-condition specifics

When the bug is race-driven (double-spend, coupon stacking, TOCTOU):

• HTTP/2 single-packet attack for tightest timing window. Turbo Intruder is the canonical tool; or curl with --http2 --next to bundle requests in one TCP packet.
• Measure 5-10 runs before claiming reliability. Probabilistic successes need a hit-rate ("8/10 attempts succeeded") — single successes look like flakes to triagers.
• Burst size matters — 20-50 parallel requests for most cloud- backed targets; some need 100+ to defeat distributed locking.
• Document the timing window — milliseconds between check and use.

Quantification format

Triagers reward concrete dollar / quota figures. Always include:

• Victim count if cross-user (N other users' coupons drained)
• Dollar amount if financial ($X redeemed for $0)
• Quota / scale if quota-bypass (1000 free-trial accounts in 10s)
• Multiplier vs. legitimate use (50x permitted invite count)

"Business logic flaw allows abuse" without numbers gets DOWNGRADE. "Business logic flaw allows $50K/day in fraudulent withdrawals" pays critical.

State-tampering checks

For every state-carrying request, test:

• Negative numbers in every numeric field (price, quantity, quota, balance, count, refund_amount).
• Decimal underflow — 0.0001 × large quantity for currency rounding bugs (banker's-rounding accumulation).
• Sign flip on transfer — from=A&to=B&amount=-100 increases A's balance.
• One-shot tokens reused — invite-accept, password-reset, MFA-enrollment, voucher-redeem.
• State value substitution — order_status sent client-side (status=fulfilled from status=pending → free goods).
• Workflow checkpoint bypass — POST direct to step 5 endpoint without completing 1-4.

Output: H1 Weakness #28

Report as "Business Logic Errors" — title MUST quantify impact:

• GOOD: "Race Condition in Coupon Redemption Allows Stacking $5K Discount on Single Purchase"
• GOOD: "Negative-Quantity Cart Manipulation Yields Unlimited Free Goods (PoC: $2.5K test purchase)"
• BAD: "Price Manipulation in Cart"
• BAD: "Workflow Bypass Possible"

Include in every result:

1. Exact request that triggers the abuse + response
2. Dollar / quota / scale quantification
3. Chain target if applicable (admin context, financial impact, ATO)
4. Repro steps with role assumptions (own account vs. crafted-state vs. victim account)
5. Real-world parallel CVE / disclosure for severity calibration

If standalone with no quantified impact AND no chain → record EXHAUSTED. Don't draft.

Brain Integration

Before starting, check your memory for brain briefings. Skip EXHAUSTED vectors. Focus on ACTIVE leads.

After completing, label every finding: CONFIRMED (with $ impact) / CHAIN-CANDIDATE (paired with downstream class) / EXHAUSTED (no quantification, no chain). The "what was the dollar amount" answer goes in the brain record.

Top-Tier Operator Standard

Business-logic hunting is accounting with adversarial inputs.

• Start with the ledger: price, credits, quota, subscription state, approval status, inventory, payout, refund, coupon, invite, entitlement, and audit trail.
• Build the legal baseline first, then test reorder, replay, duplicate, race, negative quantity, stale idempotency key, currency mismatch, tier downgrade, and cross-account transfer.
• A reportable bug must quantify loss or unauthorized gain: dollars, credits, paid feature access, irreversible state change, or approval bypass.
• Kill "weird UI state" unless the backend accepts it and a durable business artifact changes.
• Chain partials into a paid impact: trial abuse to subscription, invite confusion to role escalation, refund drift to balance increase, or approval bypass to external action.