Criticism Self Criticism logo

Criticism Self Criticism

CommunityPopular
HughYau
criticism-self-criticism

批评与自我批评:在工作完成、阶段验收、收到批评或同类错误反复出现时,对成果和过程做诚实、具体、基于事实的审视,输出可执行的改进项,并处理外来批评而不辩解。触发信号包括 review、复盘、审查、"帮我看看有没有问题"、"你确定吗";任务刚开始或只是单步查询时不触发。 English: Criticism and self-criticism. After delivery, at a review checkpoint, on receiving criticism, or when the same mistake recurs, examine the result and the process honestly and concretely, produce actionable fixes, and accept valid criticism without defensiveness. Triggers include review, retrospective, audit, "check this for problems", "are you sure"; skip at the start of a task or for one-step lookups.

Overview

PublisherHughYau
Repositoryqiushi-skill
Skill namecriticism-self-criticism
Stars
3.8K
Forks
285
Bundled files
2
LicenseMIT
Links
  • Markdown instructions

    A SKILL.md file the model loads on demand, so it only costs tokens when a request actually matches.

  • Works with any LLM

    AI skills are plain Markdown, not provider-specific code, so this works with GPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, or a local model.

  • 2 bundled files

    Scripts, templates, and references the model can read while it works. Files are read-only and never executed.

  • Open source

    Published by HughYau on GitHub. Read the source before you install it.

Installation

Install the Criticism Self Criticism AI skill in TypingMind to use it with any LLM, or drop it into another agent that reads SKILL.md.

1

Install in TypingMind

TypingMind installs a skill straight from its GitHub folder — it reads SKILL.md, bundles the resource files, and stores the result locally.

  1. Open the app and go to Plugins → Skills.
  2. Choose "Install from GitHub".
  3. Paste the skill folder URL below and confirm.
  4. Enable the skill in any chat where you want it available.
Plugins → Skills → Add skill → From GitHub URL, then paste the folder URL and press Continue.
2

Install in another agent

Any agent that reads the Agent Skills format can use this skill — copy the folder into that agent's skills directory.

Claude Code — .claude/skills
git clone --depth 1 https://github.com/HughYau/qiushi-skill.git /tmp/qiushi-skill
mkdir -p .claude/skills
cp -r /tmp/qiushi-skill/skills/criticism-self-criticism .claude/skills/criticism-self-criticism
Restart Claude Code after copying so it picks up the new skill.

Use it in TypingMind

Enable Criticism Self Criticism in any TypingMind chat and the model takes it from there. Its name and description sit in the system prompt, and the moment a request matches, the model loads the full instructions itself — you never invoke it by hand, and it costs no tokens until it is actually used.

The model loads Criticism Self Criticism on its own as soon as a request matches it.

Works with any AI model

AI skills are plain Markdown instructions rather than provider-specific code, so Criticism Self Criticism is not tied to the model it was written for. Install it once in TypingMind and use it with GPT-5, Claude, Gemini, Grok, DeepSeek, Mistral, Llama, or a local model you run yourself — all on your own API keys.

  • Loaded only when it is needed

    The system prompt carries just the name and description. The instructions are fetched on the first matching request, so an idle skill costs nothing.

  • Switch models mid-chat

    Because the skill is instructions rather than code, changing model does not break it — the next model reads the same SKILL.md.

Skill instructions

This is the SKILL.md content the model loads. Read it before installing — a skill is instructions your model will follow.

批评与自我批评

"房子是应该经常打扫的,不打扫就会积满了灰尘。" —— 《论联合政府》

目的是治病救人:每指出一个问题,就给一个改进;肯定做得好的部分;对事不对人。

用 / 不用

用:

  • 一项工作完成,交付前审视
  • 收到用户或审查者的批评
  • 同类错误反复出现,要找根本原因
  • 阶段性节点复盘

不用:

  • 任务刚开始,没有可审视的成果
  • 用户在实时指导,反馈已即时纳入
  • 紧急修复进行中:先修完,再复盘

操作规程

自我批评

  1. 复述原定目标与验收标准。
  2. 重新看制品本身(diff、输出、测试结果),不看自己的叙述;自己知道的问题必须主动暴露。
  3. 逐项对照 review-checklist.md:完整性、正确性、方法论、质量。
  4. 问题写具体:哪一步、哪个文件、造成什么影响、根本原因是哪条方法论失误(跳过了调查?没验证?分散了力量?)。
  5. 输出审视报告(模板见下)。问题表为空时,必须写"未发现需要改正的问题,原因是 ……"。
  6. 需要独立视角时,派遣 self-critic 子 agent 在新鲜上下文中审查制品;主线不得替它预填结论。

处理外来批评

  1. 先完整听完,不急于辩解。
  2. 用事实核对:对 → 立即接受并改正,说明改了什么;不对 → 用证据说明,不情绪化。
  3. 表面接受实际不改,比拒绝批评更坏。

输出模板

## 工作审视报告
原定目标 / 验收标准:……
完成情况:[x] …… [ ] ……(原因)

| 严重程度 | 问题(具体到步骤 / 文件) | 根本原因 | 改进 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 必须改正 | | | |
| 应当改正 | | | |
| 建议改进 | | | |

做得好的地方:……
下次重点关注:……

纪律

  • 禁止"做得不够好"这类无信息量描述。
  • 禁止没有改进建议的批评,禁止针对性格的评价。
  • 禁止基于猜测的批评;不确定的标"存疑"。
  • 报告末尾把"下次重点关注"直接交给用户:这是跨会话唯一可靠的跟进机制。

交接

  • 报告中的"必须改正" → 立即修复并回到 practice-cognition 验证
  • 问题根源是主要矛盾没抓对 → contradiction-analysis

原著依据:original-texts.md

Bundled files

The model reads these on demand while the skill is loaded. They are exposed as readable files and are never executed.

Frequently asked questions

What does the Criticism Self Criticism AI skill do?

批评与自我批评:在工作完成、阶段验收、收到批评或同类错误反复出现时,对成果和过程做诚实、具体、基于事实的审视,输出可执行的改进项,并处理外来批评而不辩解。触发信号包括 review、复盘、审查、"帮我看看有没有问题"、"你确定吗";任务刚开始或只是单步查询时不触发。 English: Criticism and self-criticism. After delivery, at a review checkpoint, on receiving criticism, or when the same mistake recurs, examine the result and the process honestly and concretely, produce actionable fixes, and accept valid criticism without defensiveness. Triggers include review, retrospective, audit, "check this for problems", "are you sure"; skip at the start of a task or for one-step lookups.

Why use Criticism Self Criticism on TypingMind?

Because you install it once and use it with any model. Criticism Self Criticism is plain Markdown rather than provider-specific code, so the same skill runs on GPT-5, Claude, Gemini, Grok, or a local model — and you can switch model mid-chat without it breaking. TypingMind runs on your own API keys, so you pay providers directly instead of a per-seat subscription, and your skills and chats stay in your own storage.

How do I install Criticism Self Criticism in TypingMind?

Open Plugins → Skills → Install from GitHub in TypingMind and paste https://github.com/HughYau/qiushi-skill/tree/main/skills/criticism-self-criticism. TypingMind reads its SKILL.md and bundles its files and installs it as a skill you can enable per chat.

Which AI models can use Criticism Self Criticism?

Any model you connect in TypingMind. AI skills are plain Markdown instructions rather than provider-specific code, so GPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and local models can all load this skill when a request matches it.

How many AI models can I use with Criticism Self Criticism?

As many as you like. As long as a model supports skills, you can use Criticism Self Criticism with it — GPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, DeepSeek, Mistral, Llama and more — all on TypingMind with your own API keys.

Is the Criticism Self Criticism AI skill free?

Yes. It is published on GitHub by HughYau under the MIT license. You only pay your own AI provider for the tokens you use.

What are AI skills?

An AI skill is a reusable instruction bundle that teaches an AI model how to do one specific task. It follows the open Agent Skills format: a SKILL.md file with a name and description, plus any scripts, templates or reference files the model may need. The model reads the instructions only when your request matches the skill, so an installed skill costs nothing until it is used.

How are AI skills different from plugins or MCP servers?

A plugin or MCP server gives a model new tools to call — code that runs somewhere and returns a result. An AI skill gives the model knowledge and process instead: how to approach a task, which steps to follow, what good output looks like. Skills are plain Markdown, so they need no server, no API key and no runtime, and they work with any model.

View all

Set up your own AI workspace now

Get notified about new features and future giveaways by subscribing to our newsletter 👇