Experiment Queue

Experiment Queue

⏱ External cadence: visibility only. This skill already runs its own detached server-side scheduler (60s poll + depends_on + wave transitions). Use its status output for overnight visibility (N done / N running / N pending); do not wrap it in a second /loop / CronCreate poll — that duplicates the scheduler on an uncoordinated clock and races the wave-transition logic it was built to prevent. See shared-references/external-cadence.md ("don't duplicate an existing scheduler").

Orchestrate large batches of ML experiments on SSH remote GPU servers with proper state tracking, OOM retry, stale cleanup, and wave transitions.

When to Use This Skill

Use when /run-experiment is insufficient:

• ≥10 jobs that need batching across GPUs
• Multi-seed sweeps (e.g., 21 seeds × 12 cells)
• Wave transitions (run wave 1, wait, run wave 2, wait, run wave 3...)
• Teacher+student chains (train teacher then distill; auto-trigger student after teacher done)
• OOM-prone configs where you need to retry with different GPU or wait
• Mixed seed grids where failed cells need re-running

Do NOT use for:

• Single ad-hoc experiment (use /run-experiment)
• Modal/Vast.ai deployments (those have their own orchestration)
• Experiments that need manual inspection between runs

Why This Exists

Based on session audit (2026-04-16), the major wall-clock sinks in multi-seed grid experiments are:

1. Stale screens — python finishes, wandb uploads, screen hangs, next wave blocked
2. OOM on shared GPU — previous job's memory not yet released
3. Wave race — new wave launches before previous wave fully settles
4. Missing checkpoints — student launches before teacher saved
5. Parser duplication — rewriting multi-seed analysis python every batch

All of these are pure engineering friction that can be orchestrated.

Core Concepts

Environment contract: queue jobs assume the target env is already built and validated per ../shared-references/compute-env-contract.md (spec-hash ledger + kernel witness). A wave of jobs dying at import time = the env contract was skipped, not a queue bug; check the provider's .aris/compute/<provider>.md ledger before re-queueing.

Job Manifest

A manifest lists jobs with explicit state:

yamlCopy code
project: my_grid_experiment
cwd: /home/user/your_project
conda: my_env
# Optional: override conda hook path if conda is not at a standard location.
# Can be a bare path (wrapped automatically) or a full `eval "$(... shell.bash hook)"` string.
# Falls back to auto-detect of ~/anaconda3, ~/miniconda3, /opt/anaconda3, etc.,
# or the ARIS_CONDA_HOOK environment variable.
# conda_hook: /custom/path/to/conda
ssh: gpu-server
default_cmd: >
  python run_distill.py --backbone softmax --lam 0.5
  --K 500 --L 96 --W 16 --n_steps 30000 --batch_size 128 --lr 1e-4

preconditions:
  - type: checkpoint_exists
    path: checkpoints/transformer/teacher_L96_K500_N{N}.pt

gpus: [0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]
max_parallel: 8
gpu_free_threshold_mib: 500  # optional, default 500; raise for shared servers, lower for tight packing
oom_retry:
  delay: 120
  max_attempts: 3

jobs:
  - id: s200_N64_n50K
    args: {seed: 200, n_hidden: 64, n_train_subset: 50000, subset_seed: 2024}
  - id: s200_N128_n50K
    args: {seed: 200, n_hidden: 128, n_train_subset: 50000, subset_seed: 2024}
  # ... 14 more

Job State Machine

Copy code
pending → running → completed
                 ↘ failed_oom → pending (after delay) [retry up to N]
                 ↘ failed_other → stuck (needs manual inspection)
stale screen (process gone, screen lingering) → failed_other → stuck

Operator note on stuck (the agent's move, not the queue's): the queue deterministically parks failed_other jobs as stuck — that part is code and unchanged. Before handing a stuck batch to the human, the OPERATING AGENT should check: if the same failure repeats across jobs, try ONE clean reimplement of the agent-generated wrapper/attempt script only — never user/project source (run_*.py you didn't write), the manifest, queue state, logs, or results (see shared-references/external-cadence.md § Let a broken attempt restart, not just patch). Reserve the human handoff for contract/environment doubts, not merely broken attempt code.

Wave Orchestration

A "wave" is a batch of jobs that fit available GPUs. Next wave only starts when:

1. All current-wave python processes have exited
2. No stale screens remain for current-wave tags
3. GPU memory has dropped below threshold (≤500 MiB)
4. Precondition checks pass for next-wave jobs

Workflow

Step 1: Parse Manifest / Build from Grid

Input can be:

• YAML manifest (explicit job list, recommended for complex cases)
• Grid spec (Cartesian product of param values, e.g., N=[64,128,256] × n=[50K,150K,500K,652K])
• Natural language description (Claude parses into manifest)

Bind the run identifiers once so every later step (manifest save, scp, launch, monitor, resume) refers to the same paths. Set these as local shell variables before generating the manifest:

bashCopy code
# REPLACE the placeholder path before running, or pre-export PROJECT_DIR:
PROJECT_DIR="${PROJECT_DIR:?set PROJECT_DIR to the local project root}"
RUN_TS=$(date -u +%Y%m%dT%H%M%SZ)             # one timestamp per run, reused everywhere
LOCAL_RUN_DIR="$PROJECT_DIR/experiment_queue/$RUN_TS"
mkdir -p "$LOCAL_RUN_DIR"

Save the built manifest to $LOCAL_RUN_DIR/manifest.json for reproducibility.

Step 2: Pre-flight

• Check SSH connection works
• Check conda env exists on remote
• Check cwd exists on remote
• Check all preconditions (checkpoints, input files)
• Check GPU availability (at least max_parallel free GPUs)

If any precondition fails, show user which jobs are blocked and why.

Step 3: Launch Scheduler

The canonical scheduler implementation lives in skills/experiment-queue/scripts/queue_manager.py (Phase 3.3 move, Arch C). tools/experiment_queue/queue_manager.py is now a Python os.execv shim retained for legacy resolver-chain compatibility. Three preliminaries before launch.

3a. Resolve the local helper directory. The two helpers (queue_manager.py, build_manifest.py) now sit under skills/experiment-queue/scripts/ in the ARIS repo, with shims at tools/experiment_queue/ for legacy resolver layers. Use this hybrid chain so the skill works from any project layout:

bashCopy code
# Layer 0: self-contained (CC 1.0+ exposes $CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR).
QUEUE_TOOLS=""
if [ -n "${CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR:-}" ] && [ -f "$CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR/scripts/queue_manager.py" ]; then
  QUEUE_TOOLS="$CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR/scripts"
fi
# Layers 1-4: legacy chain via tools/experiment_queue/ shims.
if [ -z "$QUEUE_TOOLS" ]; then
  cd "$(git rev-parse --show-toplevel 2>/dev/null || pwd)" || exit 1
  if [ -z "${ARIS_REPO:-}" ] && [ -f .aris/installed-skills.txt ]; then
      ARIS_REPO=$(awk -F'\t' '$1=="repo_root"{print $2; exit}' .aris/installed-skills.txt 2>/dev/null) || true
  fi
  if [ -z "${ARIS_REPO:-}" ] && [ -f "$HOME/.aris/repo" ]; then
      ARIS_REPO=$(cat "$HOME/.aris/repo" 2>/dev/null) || true
  fi
  QUEUE_TOOLS=".aris/tools/experiment_queue"
  [ -f "$QUEUE_TOOLS/queue_manager.py" ] || QUEUE_TOOLS="tools/experiment_queue"
  [ -f "$QUEUE_TOOLS/queue_manager.py" ] || { [ -n "${ARIS_REPO:-}" ] && QUEUE_TOOLS="$ARIS_REPO/tools/experiment_queue"; }
  [ -f "$QUEUE_TOOLS/queue_manager.py" ] || QUEUE_TOOLS=""
fi
[ -z "$QUEUE_TOOLS" ] && { echo "ERROR: experiment_queue helpers not found (layer 0: \$CLAUDE_SKILL_DIR/scripts/; layers 1-4: .aris/tools/, tools/, \$ARIS_REPO/tools/, \$ARIS_REPO/tools/ via ~/.aris/repo). Rerun install_aris.sh or smart_update.sh (refreshes ~/.aris/repo), set ARIS_REPO, or copy the canonical scripts from \$ARIS_REPO/skills/experiment-queue/scripts/." >&2; exit 1; }

The .aris/tools symlink is set up by install_aris.sh (#174). Older installs without that symlink fall through to tools/experiment_queue (works if invoked from inside the ARIS repo), $ARIS_REPO/tools/experiment_queue, or the same path resolved via the global pointer file ~/.aris/repo (#366, for installs with no project-local manifest). After Phase 3.3, each of those legacy paths contains a Python os.execv shim that forwards to the canonical skills/experiment-queue/scripts/ location, so existing users do not need to re-run anything.

3b. Compute remote paths. Use both a remote-relative form (for scp destinations — modern scp runs in SFTP mode and does NOT reliably expand $HOME in destination paths) and a $HOME-prefixed form (for ssh ... command strings, where remote bash WILL expand $HOME):

bashCopy code
REMOTE_RUN_REL=".aris_queue/runs/$RUN_TS"          # for scp destinations (relative to remote home)
REMOTE_RUN_DIR="\$HOME/$REMOTE_RUN_REL"            # for ssh command strings (literal $HOME, expanded on remote)

3c. Bootstrap the remote run directory and copy helpers + manifest. Per-invocation and idempotent. Use a unique run directory rather than /tmp so concurrent queues do not collide and so resume-after-crash is reproducible.

bashCopy code
ssh <server> "mkdir -p \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/logs\" \"\$HOME/.aris_queue\""
scp "$QUEUE_TOOLS/queue_manager.py" "$QUEUE_TOOLS/build_manifest.py" <server>:.aris_queue/
scp "$LOCAL_RUN_DIR/manifest.json" <server>:"$REMOTE_RUN_REL/manifest.json"

3d. Launch the scheduler as a detached nohup process on the SSH host:

bashCopy code
ssh <server> "nohup python3 \"\$HOME/.aris_queue/queue_manager.py\" \\
  --manifest \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/manifest.json\" \\
  --state    \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/queue_state.json\" \\
  --log-dir  \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/logs\" \\
  > \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/queue_mgr.log\" 2>&1 &"

Notes for callers:

• --log-dir is what queue_manager.py actually consumes (per-job log files for OOM detection). Do NOT pass --log <path> — that flag is declared but unused, and a single combined log breaks the per-job stale-screen / OOM heuristics.

• Persist RUN_TS / REMOTE_RUN_REL / REMOTE_RUN_DIR to disk so monitoring and resume can reload them without regenerating:

  bashCopy code
  {
    printf 'PROJECT_DIR=%q\n'    "$PROJECT_DIR"
    printf 'RUN_TS=%q\n'         "$RUN_TS"
    printf 'LOCAL_RUN_DIR=%q\n'  "$LOCAL_RUN_DIR"
    printf 'REMOTE_RUN_REL=%q\n' "$REMOTE_RUN_REL"
    printf 'REMOTE_RUN_DIR=%q\n' "$REMOTE_RUN_DIR"
  } > "$LOCAL_RUN_DIR/run_meta.txt"
  

  %q shell-escapes the values so the file is safely sourceable later. Note that REMOTE_RUN_DIR keeps a literal $HOME (do not expand it locally), which is the right form for re-use inside ssh "..." strings later.

3e. Resume an existing queue (only when the user asks). A fresh RUN_TS per invocation is correct for new queues. To resume a crashed queue, do NOT regenerate RUN_TS — reload the recorded values and re-run only the launch command (Step 3d), not the bootstrap (Step 3c):

bashCopy code
LOCAL_RUN_DIR="/abs/path/to/project/experiment_queue/<existing-run-ts>"   # the run dir to resume
. "$LOCAL_RUN_DIR/run_meta.txt"                                            # reloads PROJECT_DIR / RUN_TS / REMOTE_RUN_REL / REMOTE_RUN_DIR
# Then re-run Step 3d verbatim. Do NOT re-run Step 3c (would overwrite manifest.json + state.json).

A queue_state.json written before the 2026-08 scheduler fix records jobs the old code mis-judged as failed. Resuming it parks those jobs as stuck — they are not retried, so a state file whose jobs are all failed_other finishes with nothing launched. Delete that state file and re-run the manifest from Step 3c.

The scheduler:

• Reads manifest
• Loops: for each pending job, assign to free GPU, launch via screen
• Polls job status (every 60s)
• Detects stale screens (python exited but screen detached → kill)
• Detects OOM (CUDA OOM in log → mark failed_oom → retry after delay)
• Detects completion (expected output JSON/file exists) → mark completed
• Launches next wave when current wave settles
• Writes state to queue_state.json continuously

Step 4: Monitoring

User can check state anytime, using $REMOTE_RUN_DIR from Step 3b (or reload from $LOCAL_RUN_DIR/run_meta.txt for an older run):

bashCopy code
ssh <server> "cat \"$REMOTE_RUN_DIR/queue_state.json\"" \
  | jq '.jobs | group_by(.status) | map({(.[0].status): length}) | add'

Note: /monitor-experiment is currently focused on screen sessions, result JSONs, and W&B; it does not yet read queue_state.json directly. For queue-state monitoring, use the literal command above against the recorded REMOTE_RUN_DIR. (Tracking /monitor-experiment queue-state integration as a follow-up.)

Step 5: Post-completion

When all jobs in manifest.json are completed or stuck:

• The remote scheduler (queue_manager.py) exits cleanly with All jobs done to its own stdout (captured in $REMOTE_RUN_DIR/queue_mgr.log). It does NOT write the local summary.
• The local skill agent then aggregates state into $LOCAL_RUN_DIR/summary.md (read $REMOTE_RUN_DIR/queue_state.json, group by status, optionally pull per-job logs).
• Local skill agent invokes /analyze-results if analyze_on_complete: true.

Grid Spec Syntax

Instead of writing 24 job entries manually:

yamlCopy code
grid:
  N: [64, 128, 256]
  n: [50000, 150000, 500000, 652000]
  seed: [42, 200, 201]
template:
  id: "s${seed}_N${N}_n${n}"
  args: {seed: ${seed}, n_hidden: ${N}, n_train_subset: ${n}}

Expands to 36 jobs automatically.

Wave Chaining

For sequential phases (teacher → student):

yamlCopy code
phases:
  - name: train_teachers
    grid:
      N: [384, 512]
    template:
      cmd: python run_train.py --direction c --backbone softmax --n_hidden ${N} ...
      expected_output: checkpoints/transformer/teacher_L96_K500_N${N}.pt
  
  - name: distill_students
    depends_on: [train_teachers]        # must be a LIST, even for a single dependency
    grid:
      N: [384, 512]
      seed: [42, 200, 201]
    template:
      cmd: python run_distill.py --n_hidden ${N} --seed ${seed} ...
      expected_output: figures/distill_sw_N${N}_*_seed${seed}.json

Scheduler enforces depends_on: distill_students jobs stay pending until every train_teachers job is terminal — completed or stuck. A failed teacher does not hold its students back, so check queue_state.json for stuck jobs before trusting a dependent wave.

OOM Handling

Detect OOM from stdout:

regexCopy code
torch\.OutOfMemoryError: CUDA out of memory

On detection:

1. Mark job failed_oom
2. Kill screen
3. Wait oom_retry.delay seconds
4. Check if current GPU is free; if not, try another free GPU
5. Requeue as pending
6. Max oom_retry.max_attempts before marking stuck

Stale Screen Detection

Every 60s, for each running screen:

1. Check screen exists (screen -ls)
2. Check python PID still running (ps -p)
3. If screen exists but python exited:
   • If expected output file exists → mark completed, kill stale screen
   • If no output file → mark failed_other, kill screen

Resume-on-restart

If scheduler crashes / is killed:

1. Read queue_state.json
2. For each running job: check screen; if still alive, keep; if not, re-evaluate state
3. For each pending: continue normally
4. Idempotent: safe to restart scheduler without losing state

Output: Summary Report

markdownCopy code
# Experiment Queue Summary

**Project**: my_grid_experiment
**Started**: 2026-04-16 11:36:29
**Completed**: 2026-04-16 18:02:14
**Total wall-clock**: 6h 25m
**Jobs**: 40 completed, 2 OOM-retried then completed, 0 stuck

## Phases
| Phase | Jobs | Success | OOM retries | Duration |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| train_teachers | 2 | 2 | 0 | 58m |
| distill_students | 24 | 24 | 2 | 4h 02m |
| multi_seed_validation | 16 | 16 | 0 | 1h 25m |

## Results Files
- 42 JSON files in `figures/distill_sw_*.json`

## Next Steps
- Run `/analyze-results` on output JSONs
- Figures auto-regen via `artifact-sync` (if configured)

Comparison with /run-experiment

Rule: Use /run-experiment for ≤5 jobs. Use experiment-queue for ≥10 jobs or anything with phases.

Key Rules

• Never overlap screens on the same GPU — always wait for memory.used < 500 MiB before launching new job
• Always write state to disk — every state change flushed to queue_state.json
• Idempotent scheduler — safe to restart; picks up from state file
• Expected-output-based completion — don't trust screen state alone; verify output file exists
• Bounded retry — max N OOM retries, then mark stuck and alert
• Dependencies enforced at launch — a wave launches only after every job in the phases it depends on has reached a terminal state. Note "terminal" includes stuck: if a teacher job fails, the phase still completes and its students launch against a missing checkpoint. Check queue_state.json for stuck jobs before trusting a dependent wave's results.

Known Failure Modes

• SSH connection drop during scheduling: scheduler keeps running on remote (nohup), just reconnect and check
• GPU reservation by another user: scheduler waits, does not pre-empt
• Disk full on remote: scheduler detects write failure, marks all pending stuck, alerts

Example Session

User: "跑 T5+T6 全部实验：T5 = N∈{80,192} × n 4 values × seed {200,201}, T6 = N∈{384,512} × n 4 values × seed {42,200,201}; T6 需要先 train teacher"

Claude invokes /experiment-queue:

1. Parses description into 2-phase manifest
2. Phase 1: T5 (16 jobs, no teacher dependency) + T6 teacher training (2 jobs)
3. Phase 2: T6 distillation (24 jobs, depends on teachers)
4. Deploys scheduler via nohup
5. Reports: "Scheduler PID 93534, total 42 jobs, estimated 6-7h wall-clock"

Then user can check anytime or wait for summary report.

See Also

• /run-experiment — single experiment deployment
• /monitor-experiment — check progress (now reads from queue_state.json)
• /analyze-results — post-hoc analysis
• skills/experiment-queue/scripts/queue_manager.py (canonical, Phase 3.3 move) — the scheduler implementation; resolved at runtime via the fallback chain in Step 3a. Legacy entry at tools/experiment_queue/queue_manager.py is an os.execv shim.
• skills/experiment-queue/scripts/build_manifest.py (canonical, Phase 3.3 move) — build manifest from grid spec; same resolution chain. Legacy entry at tools/experiment_queue/build_manifest.py is an os.execv shim.

Rationale / Source

Identified via 2026-04-16 post-mortem analysis (Codex GPT-5.5 xhigh) of a 1.5-day multi-seed paper experiment session:

• Wall-clock sink: stale screens, OOM, wave transitions, manual parser
• Token sink: re-writing orchestration code each session
• Cognitive sink: tracking which cells succeeded, which failed, which to retry

This skill targets the wall-clock sink specifically; see artifact-sync and paper-fix-auto-apply for the other two.